A Question And An Answer, But What Do You Think?

We talk a lot about writer oriented topics here on the blog because we want all of you to take that story I know is in you and get it out to the world. All of you have a great story to tell, and if I can help it reach the masses, I want to do that. (Knowing lots of rich, famous authors can’t hurt my writing career.)

This post is for readers – which all of you are, too.

The Navigators is out with Beta Readers right now (I’m writing this post a few weeks ago and scheduling it, so most of the feedback will be received by now, but bear with me) and I have a dilemma.

Look at these questions and give me your immediate reactions.

Here’s the cover unless we  change it:

TheNavigatorsDanAlatorre

Who is that story about?

Just from looking, WHAT does the cover tell you about the story?

Here’s the blurb, unless we change it:

A freak landslide uncovers a strange machine at a dangerous central Florida mine after a team of graduate students in archaeology challenge themselves to find something big during the quiet summer session. Wary of corrupt school officials suspected of selling off their discoveries, the students take the machine home and study it in secret, reaching only one realistic – and unbelievable – conclusion: It was designed to bridge the time-space continuum. It’s a time machine.

Covert testing delivers disastrous results, each worse than the prior one, sending one team member to the hospital and nearly killing another, while a third tells university faculty about the machine – leading to the ultimate power struggle. The university wants it for funding, powerful Florida Electric wants to keep the machine’s regenerating energy abilities under wraps, and competing students want to keep it for themselves. None of them care if the team comes out of it intact.

Fleeing for their lives, the team must fight against the school, the police, the army, time, and each other if they want to learn the truth about what they’ve discovered – a truth with more severe consequences than any of them can predict.

What does the blurb make you think the story is about?

 

Okay, so here’s the dilemma.

  1. I worry about people interested in character interaction being turned off by the fact that there’s a time machine in the story.
  2. I worry about getting “time machine” fans to not be disappointed with the nontraditional way I’m telling the story.

People expect a time machine story to be one where somebody goes to the future or the past and has an adventure there. Here, it’s a character driven piece where the repercussions and morality of time travel is dealt with, among other things.

And there are trips in the machine into the past. I don’t want to give it away, but it’s pretty cool,what happens. It’s an adventure!

I mean, I liked this story enough for it to be my first fiction release, I think it’s that good.

I’m hoping a well written blurb will reconcile the dilemma I see, but who knows? So I wrote a friend and here’s her reply. (I’m only not naming her because I don’t want her status or lack thereof to sway you.)

Dan,you have to write the story that is in your heart. The story that is the one you want to tell. Readers either like it or they don’t. Stories are about people. Readers relate to the protagonist and cheer them on, or hate them and cheer for failure. Whatever.
Readers stick with stories because of the behavior or one (or occasionally two) main characters. What goes on around them is not nearly as important as they are.
All stories are character driven first and have to have focus on a protagonist who leads the story through the action. Once readers are hooked on your protagonist, what follows will keep then engaged.
Don’t sweat the time machine aspect. Make your protagonist real and appealing and flawed, the rest is icing on the cake (just don’t get any crumbs in the machine).

What are your thoughts?

* If you read the book as a beta reader, try to answer without giving away spoilers, and if you HAVE to, say SPOILER ALERT first.
* If you haven’t read the book, give your opinion based on what you know from this post or what you’ve read in this blog over the past few weeks.
Thanks for the help!

 

56 thoughts on “A Question And An Answer, But What Do You Think?

  1. I think you are worrying unecessarily Dan, I am just finishing up the beta read on The Navigators and have to tell you that I haven’t enjoyed a book so much in a long time. Stop considering making it fit other people’s ideas of what you think they want to read. This story is brilliant AND very different.
    Ever heard the expression ‘you don’t need to gild the lily’ ?

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Hi Dan I am one of your beta readers and really enjoyed the story! There was action throughout until the final conclusion, and kept the reader wondering what was going to happen at the end. I loved the Missy part, she is a real cool character – you managed to incorporate different themes – action, science fiction, drama and romance.The time machine idea is real novel. Well done! PS Also love the book cover – maybe put a couple of more of the group behind Missy? Just a suggestion though. Good luck 🙂

    Like

  3. Don’t worry Dan – you are a talented writer. I know I can’t tell you not to panic too much – releasing a book is ALL about panic, in one way or another! But you have a solid product.
    The cover is very cool, it makes me think that although the protagonist is a beautiful young woman, she is not a damsel in distress but a gutsy, adventurous lady. The way she is glancing behind her already tells me that there is an undisclosed threat she has to face. The blurb is great – it is an adventure story and the time machine is an element of that; it’s not a ‘time machine story’. It strikes me as being more about finding truth and Doing The Right Thing rather than a straightforward time machine adventure, and that appeals to me far more.
    Good luck, old bean, I have nothing but the highest hopes for this!

    Liked by 2 people

  4. I really like the cover Dan and it’s clear it has something to do with time. I understand your comments about people thinking it’s solely about time travel but as soon as you mention the machine in the blurb, you dive right into the interactions and the challenges involved-well done! I assume the girl is the protagonist; the only thing you might consider adding- though I’m not sure how easy it is at this point- would be more of the students on the cover….but it’s a great cover so if you can’t change it, don’t worry. It sounds like a great read- looking forward to sitting down with it this summer!

    Liked by 1 person

    • My original ideas for the cover actually included lots more of the students. However, you end up using big images because when people are looking at the book cover on Amazon it is only about 1 inch large and so smaller people on a regular book would be almost invisible on a 1 inch Amazon representation.

      Thank you for the praise, though! You are right! It’s a great story. I hope others agree.

      Like

  5. The moment I saw the cover before I read the blurb, I figured the story was about a time machine. I really liked the cover save the font of your name, but that’s just a personal choice.
    The blurb gives a good idea of what to expect in the story, as in it makes it pretty clear it’s not all about time travel but about an adventure sorrounding the machine.
    This is my view as a reader. Hope it helps.

    Liked by 2 people

  6. Hey Dan, from the cover I figured there was an aspect involving time, so once I read the blurb I thought it all fit together rather nicely. I haven’t kept up with all your posts, but overall, it sounds like your book will appeal to a broader audience, being that it’s not a traditional time travel story. The Navigators sounds interesting. I look forward to catching up on some of your other posts. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Okay. The cover makes me think there are attractive people involved. Sad but true that makes me more interested. im thinking cute guys equals interedting dynamics. (save the moral delimas of the beauty statement for another time). I was put off with the time machine stuff. I read for relationships. I never read for science. Lol. I liked that you posed the very problem that basically covers what I’m feeling. As I’ve read your other stuff I am pretty sure there would be interesting, lol, dynamics in the story. But for me to pick it up and read I would feel the emphasis is on the characters.
    That letter from your anonymous friend is bang on. I agree with everything. I swear it just takes me one interesting character that I can relate to, to suck me into a story. I’m not sure I’m getting that from your blurb. I’m getting its a story about time travel.
    Of course you probably have me figured.out by now so you know what I like. The science stuff would appeal to thousands of others, and I’m the loser who didn’t give it a chance. So should you change anything. Probably not. Especially not.based.on anything I say.
    Shit. I’m typing this on my phone and it’s much longer then I intended. Hope it makes.sense. and is polite.
    E6

    Liked by 1 person

    • See, that is part of the challenge. Somebody like you would probably love this story but would never pick it up because it’s science fiction/time travel. To be honest, neither would I. Just hearing that makes my skin crawl because that’s not the kind of story that usually interests me. However, this story is my version of that kind of situation, so it is much more about the people in the relationships and much less about science. Although, as you know, I’m kind of a smart guy so I did put forth if you interesting scientific theories in typical Dan fashion. One or two readers said they kind of skimmed that part because it was too technical but you know what that’s going to happen. Meanwhile, i’m sure if a friend of yours recommended the story to you, you might give it a chance. It is definitely an unconventional time travel story!

      Like

  8. Hi Dan I”l be completely honest the blurb doesn’t do it for me, too much emphasis on the machine and not enough on people, no names, just generalised labels, students, team, university… Why not the class of 2016 (or whatever), Tom , Dick, Harry and Sally (or whoever) looking for excitement…then bring it on..but I don’t give a toss about the Power Company, but the egotistical maverick leading it? (just imagining). It’s the reason I didn’t offer to beta read, I need personal connections, explored, stretched, challenged. The damn shame is I know you and know you’d likely have this in your story, but you didn’t peak my interest, you didn’t sell it to me, like you did with Poggibonsi, relationship rich, and some! So for me a good cover undermined by the blurb, as stands I’d pick it up but not buy it … and please get your name in bold, hell you’re no shrinking violet what’s with with curves and swirls. Dan you’ve good friends, who as far as I can see give genuine thought through advice, take it in, squeeze it into you, not just the praise, but things to change, you’ll still be strong, single minded, a lot of fun, but write ‘people’ blurb and sell to dick-heads like me. After all this, if you still need it, I’ll beta read, I’ll even blurb it even though I’ll be crap at it!

    Liked by 2 people

  9. Again I say, that cover makes your name non- existent. if I was scanning for books by cover, the pic reminds me of Bella from that vampire series so I would pass. I don’t like whining girl books. And that’s what the cover evokes for me. I wouldn’t even get to the blurb.

    Liked by 1 person

  10. I like the cover. I thought of a time machine immediately. The premise of everyone fighting for it is logical and what would happen if idiots brag about what they have. I think, just by this post, that the biggest dilemma would be whether or not to travel in it because it would obviously change time. I can’t imagine traveling back to any major event and not trying to change it.

    Liked by 1 person

  11. Dan, I agree with your friend. Books that are character driven hook me. Once I care about the characters I as a reader will suspend believe and forgive even the most egregious editing errors. I recently wrote a post about a book with a good story premise, and I really wanted to like the book, but I could not grasp the characters. Your book sounds terrific and I can’t wait to read it.
    As to the cover, it is eye catching but no I didn’t get the premise from the cover. But I would probably turn it over and read the back blurb.
    Have you considered lowering everything a bit and leaving off the countryside picture? That was the only confusing bit, for me. Have the “time” artwork as the background for the entire cover. But still keep the black middle area with the title. This would also give you room so that your name shows up better. https://jeanswriting.com/2016/06/06/is-your-character-hiding-in-the-shadows/

    Liked by 2 people

  12. It’s not fair for me to comment because I’ve read the book already. But before I read it, i was thinking it had something to do with time (the clock) and money (I think that’s money on the left), but I thought the story was going to revolve around a female. Melissa is one of many characters. Is there a reason you chose her on the cover? I wasn’t sure what the city below was.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Well, it’s fair to comment as long as you let people know you already read the book. Then they can temper your words appropriately.

      SPOILERS AHEAD!

      SPOILER ALERT

      Melissa is on the cover because when I looked at multiple characters on the cover they were much less visible. Using one character in a large format was more visible. A young woman was a better choice because it tends to be a male-dominated story but she emerges as the central figure who has the main story arc. This would appeal to my existing customer base, married women ages 35 to 55, but also to men if there is an attractive – but not too attractive – young woman on the cover.

      The biggest part of the story is actually Melissa’s story. The idea behind that is a message to my young daughter when she would be Melissa’s age. That’s who Mr. Mills is. Me.

      It would not be difficult to get rid of the stuff below the title. But something has to be there and it has to be a certain color so right now I guess what’s there stays. For now.

      Like

  13. I love the morality aspect of the time travel part of the story–I mean the idea of it hooked me. I agree that I almost don’t care what characters do as long as I love one or two. This looks like a good read to me. I’ll have to buy a copy!

    Liked by 1 person

  14. “I worry about people interested in character interaction being turned off by the fact that there’s a time machine in the story.” No need to worry about that, Dan – there are so many ways to write about time machines and yours is just a new take on it, fast-paced and entertaining.
    The blurb is a bit wordy, I find, especially that first sentence. The sentence that sums it up for me? This one: “The university wants it for funding, powerful Florida Electric wants to keep the machine’s regenerating energy abilities under wraps, and competing students want to keep it for themselves.” If you start the blurb with something like that, you’ve conveyed the main action of the book. Then you reveal: “What is it? A time machine.”

    Liked by 1 person

  15. Dan, You can get into a vicious circle second guessing yourself as an author. Your beta readers seem very positive and I’ve found, if you picked them carefully, they are a great indicator of the reading community at large. Just make your product as clean as possible and put it out there. That’s the joy of Indie publishing. There is no middle person to feed your self-doubt and second guessing. That’s also the most scary part of indie publishing.

    Liked by 1 person

    • That’s definitely true, Don. For me, the main goal of beta readers is to make sure I didn’t make any glaring errors – I made a few small ones – and to help formulate overall ideas for blurbs and covers and things, while helping to generate interest. They have certainly done that!

      While very few of them have said anything other than extremely positive comments, it’s just as important to get input from the people who don’t like it or who think it could be better, because as you say they represent the broad populace. I don’t expect a story to appeal to everyone but the feedback can help me target who it should be marketed to. All in all, it’s lots of fun to have people talking about your story. Whether they are saying good things or bad things, it’s still your story they are talking about!

      Liked by 1 person

    • You might say I have a confidence problem. I believe that as soon as I am done with the first draft, it is worthy of publication immediately, typos and all. It’s only through trusted critique partners, an editor author friend, and betas that I even begin to realize there may be errors in the manuscript!

      Liked by 1 person

What do YOU think? Let me hear from ya.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s